Percentages are often presented as evidence in public debate, but without context they can be deeply misleading.
Percentages: why “80%” often tells you almost nothing
You’ll often hear phrases like: “80% of people support this.” “90% satisfaction.” “A strong majority agree.”
Instinctively, it sounds reassuring.
But a percentage on its own is usually meaningless. Before a percentage tells you anything useful, you need to know:
80% of how many people?
Who were they?
How were they asked?
How many didn’t respond?
Without that context, the number is just decoration.
It’s the same trick as the old advert line:
“9 out of 10 cats prefer Whiskas.” Nine out of ten of which cats? Compared to what? Percentages are often used because they hide awkward details — like low response rates, small samples, or limited choices. Saying “80% agree” sounds better than saying “very few people responded.”
Percentages can be useful — but only when they come with:
the total number,
the response rate,
and a clear explanation of how the figure was reached.
So whenever you hear “80%”, the right question is simple: 80% of what, exactly?
This is an independent website. It is not operated by Solihull Council or by any political party. It exists to help residents understand how Solihull Council works ahead of local elections.